One of the guidelines setforth by MTA states that theatres participating in the High School Drama Festival cannot produce plays performed at the festivals held the previous three years.

2007:

An Overpraised Season by Richard S. Dunlop

Jungalbook by Edward Mast

The Amazing Adventures of the Marvelous Monkey King by Elizabeth Wong

Ghost Stories by Annie Evans

The Actor's Nightmare by Christopher Durang

Greece! by Sue Gordon

Into the Woods by Stephen Soundheim

The Crane Wife by Barbara Carlisle

Borders by David Boone

2006:

Home  by Sam Art Williams

The Beautiful Beulah Belle or the Virtue’s Various Vicissitudes by Robert C. Yoh

Snapshots featuring skits and monologues by Craig Wright, Quincy Long, Deb Margolin, Michael Bigelow Dixon, Val Smith, David Lindsay-Abaire and Julie Jenson

I Never Saw Another Butterfly by Celeste Raspanti

Forever Plaid by Stuart Ross; music by James Raitt

The Katrina Project: Hell or High Water by Michael Marks and Mackensie Westmoreland

A Thousand Cranes by Kathryn Schultz Miller

Amelia Earhart by Kathryn Schultz Miller

Wiley and the Hairy Man by Susan Zeder

2005:

A Piece of My Heart by Shirley Lauro

A Grown Up Evening of Shel Silverstein by Shel Silverstein

The Diviners by Jim Leonard Jr.

I Never Saw Another Butterfly by Celeste Raspanti

The Compleat Works of Shakespeare (Abridged) adapted by Adam Long, Daniel Singer, and Jess Wingfield

Pals by David Perkins

Crow and Weasel by Jim Leonard Jr.

The Love Talker by Debroah Pryor

The Dance of the Grizzle by Roy Hudson

2004:

Freedom Summer adapted from Frank Kuhn’s Voices of FreedomSummer

The Serpent by Jean-Claude van Itallie

The Insanity of Mary Girard by Lanie Robertson

The Dear Departed by Stanley Haughton

The Bad Seed by Maxwell Anderson

Blythe Spirit by Noel Coward